Retelling Cinderella on Screen

When I did my Fairy Tale Round-up for Cinderella a few weeks ago, I forgot a perfectly lovely movie.  Beedrill pointed it out, which sent me off to Netflix to request a disc and re-watch Ever After.

It’s a charming retelling of Cinderella, starring Drew Barrymore as Danielle, a smart young woman trodden-down by her stepfamily.  Set in Renaissance-era France, there’s no magic but plenty of whimsy, and definitely a fairy tale feel.  The plot is pretty standard fare, but the characters really shine.

Danielle is a wonderful Cinderella, well-read and keenly aware of the injustices of the society around her.  I do wonder a little why she never set out to find a place away from her stepfamily, but this is mostly justified by her circle of friends among the servants and her obvious attachment to her home.  There’s also an interesting dynamic between Danielle and her stepmother, the Baroness, as Danielle longs for acceptance from “the only mother she’s ever known.”

The stepfamily is wonderful–the Baroness is nasty, demanding, and selfish, while bemoaning how hard she tries and how little everyone around her appreciates all that she does for them, and can’t everyone just put in a little more effort, please.  It reminds me a bit of The Devil Wears Prada, actually.  The older stepsister, Marguerite, is beautiful but horrid and self-absorbed, while the younger stepsister, Jacqueline, is a sympathetic if largely passive character.

Danielle’s friends among the servants are mostly minor characters, but it’s so nice that they exist–so many characters, Cinderellas and others, seem to be utterly alone in the world, which just isn’t realistic.  Danielle’s friends collectively serve the role of fairy godmother, with some help from Leonardo Da Vinci.

Danielle’s prince is Henry, and if there’s an implausible aspect of the story it’s in what Danielle sees in him.  He’s handsome enough, and he’s a prince of course, but in the beginning of the story he’s also arrogant and immature.  He grows rapidly under exposure to Danielle’s philosophy and far more mature view of the world, so I suppose he does seem to have potential.  They have a good chemistry so I believe she likes him…I’m just not always sure why!

There are some excellent funny moments in here, especially involving Da Vinci, or the stepfamily.  There’s also a sequence near the middle involving a group of gypsies that I don’t want to spoil for anyone…so I’ll just say it’s wonderful!

Any criticisms…well, the dialogue is remarkably formal at times.  It’s occasionally off-putting, though mostly I think it works with the style of the movie.  The post-ball timeline is very unclear and it’s hard to tell how much time is elapsing between events.  I’m also a bit doubtful about how quickly they contrive to hold royal weddings, and the apparent ease with which people can get in or out of royal engagements…  But all of those are minor points, far secondary to the drive of the story.

This movie reminds me a little of Robin McKinley’s Beauty.  It’s not anything too radical or innovative, but it’s a lovely retelling with a strong heroine and a sweet romance.  And any comparison to a McKinley book can be considered a high compliment!

22 thoughts on “Retelling Cinderella on Screen

  1. I thought this was a lovely film. Watched it alot when I was younger, it was a firm favourite with my cousins and I. Thank you for reminding me off it not watched it in years, I think I will be looking out for my own copy now.

      1. Isn’t it just? I blame the overload of entertainment we have now…there is always something new. So unless you consciously make an effort to buy your own copy then there won’t be anything there to remind you of an old favourite.

  2. I’ve only seen parts of this film; it was on my list of possibles for viewing for this year’s OUaT but I haven’t gotten to it yet. Funnily though, one thing that I found out about the recent version of Little Red Riding Hood that I watched was how strikingly informal the dialogue felt (use of the word ‘okay’, for instance). I’ll be curious to see how “Ever After” compares in this way.

    1. Danielle is quite formal in her language, especially when she gets philosophical, but Drew Barrymore sells it most of the time. I hope you watch it even though the challenge is ending!

      And I always cringe over slang (even “okay”) in historical fiction.

  3. Jenny

    This is one of my favorite movies! I love how they create real magic by using the wonder of the unknown combined with the courage to test out one’s thoughts and questions for real answers: real magic exists.

  4. Carl V.

    This is a really sweet film, one of my family’s favorites. We’ve watched it together many, many times over the years. It is the kind of story that retains a freshness even after multiple viewings. I believe that is because it touches on some timeless truths and on those story aspects that we’ve all grown up with. And it is well acted and just a great deal of fun.

  5. I saw part of this movie long ago, and have been thinking that I ought to find a copy and see the whole thing… someday. Thanks to your review, it’s going straight onto my TBW (to be watched) list!

  6. Sarah

    You’ve expressed exactly what makes me love this movie. And Anjelica Huston is so wonderfully nasty in this movie but I do love that moment when her character is having her hair brushed by Danielle and she starts thinking about Danielle’s father, showing she just might have a heart.

    1. Agreed, that’s a really interesting scene when Danielle is brushing her stepmother’s hair and they kind of have a nice moment. It’s fleeting, but I think it’s important for the dynamic between the two of them.

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s