The Richest Man in Bedford Falls

Continuing the Christmas movie theme this week, today I want to look at another Christmas classic, It’s a Wonderful Life.  I honestly don’t know how many times I’ve watched it–15?  20?  It’s a rare Christmas that I don’t rewatch it, at least since I was maybe eight, so it has to be a high number of times!  It’s one of those wonderful movies that I can keep on watching, and keep seeing new things.

I’d like to just assume everyone’s seen it, but I did that in a class once, when I wanted to quote a line, and was shocked that half the people present had never watched the movie.  So, a plot summary: George Bailey (Jimmy Stewart) lives in the tiny town of Bedford Falls, and has always dreamed of getting out into the world to do great things.  Circumstances, duty and responsibility keep trapping him in town.  He marries Mary (Donna Reed), and runs the Bailey Brothers Building and Loan, his father’s company which makes loans and builds houses for the working class in town.  This job puts him at odds with Mr. Potter (Lionel Barrymore), a “warped, frustrated old man” who cares only for his money and his control; as he puts it himself, “Most people hate me, but I don’t like them either, so it comes out even.”  Mr. Potter can’t stand it that he can’t control George and the Building and Loan; George hates his job but persists so that “people in town will have at least one place they can go to without crawling to Potter.”

One Christmas Eve, George gets into a terrible mess (his uncle and business partner’s fault) involving missing money, and is finally at the end of his rope.  When he contemplates killing himself, God sends Clarence Oddbody, a genial angel trying to earn his wings, who helps George by showing him what the world would be like if he had never been born.

Like Casablanca, I feel like the plot summary barely does it justice.  It’s a wonderful, complex, deftly-handled movie.  Ultimately, it’s about what is probably a nearly-universal problem, the conflicting pulls between our duty and our dreams, between our relationships and our freedom.  I love stories about people who chase their dreams and disregard the consequences.  But I also believe it’s our relationships that bring us the greatest happiness.  Like Mary, I moved back to my hometown after college, mostly because of my family.  Like George, I have big dreams of seeing the world.  Unlike George, I like to think I can combine those goals.

I feel so sad for George, especially in the beginning of the movie, when he keeps getting SO close to going out into the world, and every time something thwarts him–with his own sense of responsibility a major cause.  This would be a terrible movie if I really believed George was miserable his whole life, and then Clarence swooped in at the end to convince him everything was wonderful.  But the movie is handled more carefully than that.

There’s this very nice balance between George’s frustrations and longings, and all the happiness that really is in his life.  We see him dreaming of escaping, but we also see him surrounded by warm friends and loving family.  His frustrations and his happiness tend to be juxtaposed.  (Warning: Spoilers after this point!)  The same day he realizes his brother won’t be taking over the Building and Loan, trapping him in town, he also gets together with Mary.  He turns down a slimy offer from Potter but feels frustrated with his life, and that night Mary announces she’s having a baby.  If George’s friends came to help him only at the end, none of this would work.  Instead, there’s a definite feeling that they’re there all along.

Watching this for the 15th or 20th time, I can pay attention to the background things.  When I watched it this year, I was really drawn by the pictures on the walls.  It’s particularly striking during the bank crisis, when George is on the phone with Potter.  The two men are contrasted through their pictures.  George is in his office, with a picture of his mother on the desk (in other scenes, we also see he has his father’s picture on the wall).  Potter is in his study, with an enormous portrait of himself over the fireplace.  Near the end, when George is frustrated and lashing out, he knocks over a model bridge in his living room, which is sitting on a work table.  Behind the bridge, though, you can see a line of photos: Mary, George’s mother, Uncle Billy…  There’s also a picture of Lincoln.  Contrast that to our view of Potter’s office in the next scene, where he seems to have a bust of Napoleon–and another portrait of himself.  The model bridge also gives me hope that George hasn’t completely given up on his dreams of building great things.

This is ultimately a beautiful movie about what matters most in life, and it delivers the message without being cloying or overly sentimental.  That takes a deft touch too.  One example–George makes several impassioned speeches, about pulling together, or about what really counts, or occasionally fighting with Potter.  His most beautiful speeches are generally disregarded by his audience.  He makes a wonderful, passionate speech during the bank crisis; the crowd stares at him, then says, “Yeah, but we need money!”  This not only demonstrates George’s frustrations, it also saves the scenes from being too over the top.  If everyone applauded at the end, it would turn into sentimentalist nonsense.

Instead, it all builds up to the final message of the movie, a toast from George’s brother: “To my big brother George, the richest man in town.”  The beautiful part is that it’s not a tacked-on message.  It’s there throughout the movie, and I think George really does know all along that, as Clarence says, “No man is a failure who has friends.”  Much earlier in the movie, George is speaking about his father to Potter, and says, “In my book, he died a much richer man than you’ll ever be.”  Because he had character, and he cared about people.

George did have a wonderful life all along, and I think he knew it–he just didn’t know that he knew it.

So how does George wind up, after his experience on Christmas Eve?  We don’t know, but I like to think maybe he ends up a little like, ironically, Lionel Barrymore’s character in another Frank Capra movie, You Can’t Take It With You.  He never gets rich, but he presides over a big happy family, friends with all his neighbors, appreciating the people around him.

10 thoughts on “The Richest Man in Bedford Falls

  1. Dennis

    If there is a tragic figure in the movie, it’s Potter. Near the end, George offers him an olive branch by shouting out in all sincerity, “Merry Christmas, Mr. Potter!” But Potter doesn’t accept the good wish, or even seem to “get it,” being too absorbed in his own bitterness. We don’t feel sorry for George, but we might feel sorry for Potter, who will never love or be loved.

    1. I might have felt sorry for Potter somewhere early in the movie, but I lose all sympathy for him when he tells George he’s worth more dead than alive–especially when Potter knows exactly what’s going on, and could solve George’s problem just by being honest!

      That reminds me of another interesting point about their two characters, revealed in that scene. George offers Potter his life insurance, and mentions what it pays out in his death. Potter only cares what it could be redeemed for–because why should Potter bother with life insurance, when he has no one he would want to leave money to?

      I also wonder about the silent man pushing Potter’s chair, who saw the whole thing too but doesn’t say a word…

    2. ensign_beedrill

      Potter makes me so angry, and it’s not because of who his character is for most of the film. I do feel sort of bad for him up until the point when he finds the $8000 and knows that it belongs to Uncle Billy but does nothing and lets George take the fall. Rotten, rotten, rotten.

  2. ensign_beedrill

    This is one of my most favorite movies. It makes me cry every time. Heck, I’m barely holding it in now just thinking about it.

    Everything you said is absolutely true, but I wanted to add something that gets me at the end. George spends his life always helping other people and doing what’s right by others, but when it comes time that he needs help, he doesn’t think to ask. He would never. And when all those people come pouring through his door to give him money and help him out, well, he sees what it’s like to be on the receiving end of what he’s been giving his whole life. He sees that all he needed to do was ask and his friends would be there to bail him out of anything.

    Oh. And I just love Clarence.

    1. I LOVE your point about George never thinking to ask for help. Something I would have said too, if the post hadn’t already been quite long… 🙂 At the very beginning of the movie, when we hear all the murmured prayers, someone says of George that he always thinks about other people and never himself. He always sees the things he can do to help other people, but he never ASKS for help. He doesn’t even tell Mary his problems, and his mother told him that Mary was the one who would have the answers (and she does!) I think it’s so interesting that when George is seeing the world without him, he gets out by asking to live again–but also by asking Clarence for help.

      I guess George did try to ask Potter for help, but that of course was a horrible mistake… And then Potter told him no one else would help him and would instead condemn him, but that was because Potter judged everyone else by how HE would react…which almost makes me feel sad for Potter, if he really believes everyone else in the world is the same as he is.

      Anyway, yes, I think George’s issues with asking for help are fascinating. And Clarence is wonderful!

      1. ensign_beedrill

        Yeah, he asks Potter for help, and he mentioned to Potter that he tried to get into contact with Sam. The thing is, those are the only two people he figured he could ask because nobody else he knows has that kind of money. To him it would be a loan that he would pay back. When all those folks start dumping cash on his table, you just get the feeling that they don’t expect to be paid back.

  3. George’s brother’s toast to him at the very end of the movie, with all his family and friends around after they’ve rallied to help him on Christmas Eve, is the heart of this film. It’s beautiful and touching and sends a powerful message – all at once. Thanks for a great review.

  4. Great post 😀 Jimmy Stewart is a great actor, and It’s a Wonderful Life is a really good movie. I’ve only watched it maybe three times, but I’ve enjoyed it every time. The points you bring up are very insightful, things I’ve never noticed. I love the importance of family in the movie, and one of the funniest parts is where George is really depressed, after looking all over for the money; he goes home and everyone is happy, but his wife senses something is wrong. They go into the kitchen together, and the littlest boy follows them saying, ‘Scuse me; scuse me’ several times. George finally turns around and asks him why he’s saying that. ‘I burped,’ the little boy responds.

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s