A Concert from the Harper Hall

https://i0.wp.com/opland-freeman.com/pernmusic/images/B000CAFWKQ.MH.jpgIt’s funny the things you can find once it occurs to you to look for them.  I’ve loved Anne McCaffrey’s Pern poetry for years and years, the snatches of verses that, in context, are the songs of the Harper Hall.  In the course of the January Dragonflight group-read, it occurred to me to do a search on Amazon to see if Masterharper Robinton’s harpers have put out any CDs–and they have!

Well, not exactly.  🙂  But Tania Opland and Mike Freeman worked directly with Anne McCaffrey to put together two CDs of music inspired by Pern, much of it using the lyrics described in the book.

Can I just pause for a moment here to say how completely amazing that is?  I mean, Harper Hall songs!  Really!

I admit I was a little nervous on purchasing…this could, after all, go very badly if I didn’t like how the songs were done.  Fortunately, I like the music quite a bit overall.  It has a very acoustic, folk-song style that feels eminently appropriate to the context.  You couldn’t possibly play Menolly’s or Robinton’s songs on an electric guitar.  They need pipes and strings and though I have no musical expertise to recognize exactly what instruments are being used, this feels right.  Amazon tells me it draws from a variety of musical traditions, and I can most clearly hear the Celtic.

Most exciting, unquestionably, is that we get to hear songs I recognize from within the novels. I had to buy both albums because favorite poems/songs were split between them.  The Masterharper of Pern has more of the traditional ballads and, obviously, Robinton-related songs.  Sunset’s Gold has songs from Menolly, heroine and songster of the Harper Hall Trilogy.

Some of the tracks are instrumental, and I must admit those were not as interesting to me, though some do relate to book events.  But that’s me–I almost always prefer words in my music.

The Masterharper of Pern has a number of the songs that figure in Dragonflight.  I particularly love “The Duty Song,” which runs through all the key roles within Pernese society, and how all must come together to serve their unique purpose.  “Fighting Thread” is also excellent, about the dragonmen rising to fight their ancient enemy.  That one sticks in my head somehow.  Most exciting here is “The Question Song” which is suitably spooky, if maybe not quite the soul-capturing mystery described in the book (but what could be?)  I have mixed feelings about “Lessa’s Ride.”  Parts of it are lovely, but I would have liked a melody that was more epic and heroic, considering the subject.  On the other hand, “March of the Wings” gives me that more stirring melody I was looking for.  You can just feel the dragons soaring up in formation.

https://i0.wp.com/opland-freeman.com/pernmusic/images/B001QVJC6A.SG.jpgSunset’s Gold has many of my favorites from the Harper Hall Trilogy, brought to life very satisfactorily.  Menolly’s “Run!” song is suitably toe-tapping, and “Brekke’s Cry” is eerie.  I would have liked “The Little Queen” to be catchier somehow, but it’s been growing on me.  I really enjoy “Gather Day,” which very much captures the festive atmosphere (and the lyrics refer to bubbly pies!)  “Sunset’s Gold” and “Sweet Sea” aren’t ones I particularly remember from the books, but they’re beautiful songs in their own right, and would be even if they weren’t part of the larger context.

So, all my friends who read Dragonflight and especially those who liked the poetry…you really, really have to explore these CDs! 🙂

Musician’s Site: http://opland-freeman.com/pernmusic/index.htm

Buy it here: The Masterharper of Pern and Sunset’s Gold

12 thoughts on “A Concert from the Harper Hall

  1. dianem57

    What’s amazing to me is that, thanks to the wonders of the Internet (and Amazon) you can find this music without even knowing it existed before you did your search – zero advertising from the artists. I love living in the digital age!

  2. RE: The Masterharper of Pern CD. How cool is that? Even if I don’t yet recognize the songs and even if they are instrumental, it would be great to listen to the CD while reading the Pern books — a great mood-setter. I’m relieved that you can hear the Celtic in there because that’s how I imagined the music in the first place. Thanks for the heads up Cheryl.

  3. Can I just say, THANK YOU for reviewing these? I’ve had them on my Amazon wish list for ages, but haven’t quite had the courage to get them, because I was so worried about being disappointed. As a singer and one-time folk musician myself, I have a mental… well, image isn’t the right word for music, but you know what I mean…of what these songs should sound like. After reading your review, I feel much better about ordering them.

    1. YES–I had a clear mental “image” of the songs too, and it made me nervous…but I was far too curious to resist. And Amazon’s samples made me feel like it couldn’t be TOO bad. I’m glad I took the plunge!

      I hope you enjoy these if you order them!

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s